<?xml version="1.0"?>
<div class="add">

<b>let </b><font color="Maroon" title="c3">R</font> be    <a href="relset_1.html#M2" title="RELSET_1:mode.2">Relation</a> of <font color="Maroon" title="c1">X</font>,<font color="Maroon" title="c2">Y</font>; <a class="txt" onclick="hs(this)" href="javascript:()"><i><font color="Red">::  thesis: </font></i></a><span class="hide"> <font color="Maroon" title="c3">R</font> is <a href="zfmisc_1.html#V1" title="ZFMISC_1:attr.1">trivial</a></span><br/>

<b>assume </b><a NAME="E1:4_1_1"/>
not <font color="Maroon" title="c3">R</font> is <a href="zfmisc_1.html#V1" title="ZFMISC_1:attr.1">trivial</a>
 ; <a class="txt" onclick="hs(this)" href="javascript:()"><i><font color="Red">::  thesis: </font></i></a><span class="hide"> contradiction</span><br/>

<b>then consider </b><font color="Maroon" title="c4">a1</font>, <font color="Maroon" title="c5">a2</font> being    <a href="hidden.html#M1" title="HIDDEN:mode.1">set</a> <b> such that </b><br/><a NAME="E3:4_1_1"/><i><font color="Green" title="E3">A1</font></i>: 
( <font color="Maroon" title="c4">a1</font> <a href="hidden.html#R2" title="HIDDEN:pred.2">in</a> <font color="Maroon" title="c3">R</font> &amp; <font color="Maroon" title="c5">a2</font> <a href="hidden.html#R2" title="HIDDEN:pred.2">in</a> <font color="Maroon" title="c3">R</font> &amp; <font color="Maroon" title="c4">a1</font> <a href="hidden.html#NR2" title="HIDDEN:NR.2">&lt;&gt;</a> <font color="Maroon" title="c5">a2</font> )
 <b>by </b><i><a class="ref" href="realset1.html#T14" title="REALSET1:th.14">REALSET1:14</a></i>;<br/>
<a NAME="E4:4_1_1"/><i><font color="Green" title="E4">A2</font></i>: 
( ( <font color="Maroon" title="c1">X</font> is <a href="xboole_0.html#V1" title="XBOOLE_0:attr.1">empty</a> or  ex <font color="Olive" title="b1">x</font> being   <a href="hidden.html#M1" title="HIDDEN:mode.1">set</a>  st <font color="Maroon" title="c1">X</font> <a href="hidden.html#R1" title="HIDDEN:pred.1">=</a> <span class="p1"><a href="tarski.html#K1" title="TARSKI:func.1">{</a><span class="default"><font color="Olive" title="b1">x</font></span><a href="tarski.html#K1" title="TARSKI:func.1">}</a></span> ) &amp; ( <font color="Maroon" title="c2">Y</font> is <a href="xboole_0.html#V1" title="XBOOLE_0:attr.1">empty</a> or  ex <font color="Olive" title="b1">y</font> being   <a href="hidden.html#M1" title="HIDDEN:mode.1">set</a>  st <font color="Maroon" title="c2">Y</font> <a href="hidden.html#R1" title="HIDDEN:pred.1">=</a> <span class="p1"><a href="tarski.html#K1" title="TARSKI:func.1">{</a><span class="default"><font color="Olive" title="b1">y</font></span><a href="tarski.html#K1" title="TARSKI:func.1">}</a></span> ) )
 
<b>by </b><i><a class="ref" href="realset1.html#D4" title="REALSET1:def.4">REALSET1:def 4</a></i>;<br/>
<div><a class="txt" onclick="hsNdiv(this)" href="javascript:()" title="4_1_1_1"><b>per </b></a><a class="txt" onclick="hs(this)" href="javascript:()"><b>cases </b></a><span class="hide"><a NAME="E1:4_1_1_1"/>
( ( <font color="Maroon" title="c1">X</font> is <a href="xboole_0.html#V1" title="XBOOLE_0:attr.1">empty</a> &amp; <font color="Maroon" title="c2">Y</font> is <a href="xboole_0.html#V1" title="XBOOLE_0:attr.1">empty</a> ) or ( <font color="Maroon" title="c1">X</font> is <a href="xboole_0.html#V1" title="XBOOLE_0:attr.1">empty</a> &amp;  ex <font color="Olive" title="b1">x</font> being   <a href="hidden.html#M1" title="HIDDEN:mode.1">set</a>  st <font color="Maroon" title="c2">Y</font> <a href="hidden.html#R1" title="HIDDEN:pred.1">=</a> <span class="p1"><a href="tarski.html#K1" title="TARSKI:func.1">{</a><span class="default"><font color="Olive" title="b1">x</font></span><a href="tarski.html#K1" title="TARSKI:func.1">}</a></span> ) or  ex <font color="Olive" title="b1">x</font> being   <a href="hidden.html#M1" title="HIDDEN:mode.1">set</a>  st <br/>( <font color="Maroon" title="c1">X</font> <a href="hidden.html#R1" title="HIDDEN:pred.1">=</a> <span class="p1"><a href="tarski.html#K1" title="TARSKI:func.1">{</a><span class="default"><font color="Olive" title="b1">x</font></span><a href="tarski.html#K1" title="TARSKI:func.1">}</a></span> &amp; <font color="Maroon" title="c2">Y</font> is <a href="xboole_0.html#V1" title="XBOOLE_0:attr.1">empty</a> ) or  ex <font color="Olive" title="b1">x</font> being   <a href="hidden.html#M1" title="HIDDEN:mode.1">set</a>  st <br/>( <font color="Maroon" title="c1">X</font> <a href="hidden.html#R1" title="HIDDEN:pred.1">=</a> <span class="p1"><a href="tarski.html#K1" title="TARSKI:func.1">{</a><span class="default"><font color="Olive" title="b1">x</font></span><a href="tarski.html#K1" title="TARSKI:func.1">}</a></span> &amp;  ex <font color="Olive" title="b2">y</font> being   <a href="hidden.html#M1" title="HIDDEN:mode.1">set</a>  st <font color="Maroon" title="c2">Y</font> <a href="hidden.html#R1" title="HIDDEN:pred.1">=</a> <span class="p1"><a href="tarski.html#K1" title="TARSKI:func.1">{</a><span class="default"><font color="Olive" title="b2">y</font></span><a href="tarski.html#K1" title="TARSKI:func.1">}</a></span> ) )
 </span><b>by </b><i><a class="txt" href="#E4:4_1_1"><i><font color="Green" title="E4">A2</font></i></a></i>;<br/><div class="add"><div><a class="txt" onclick="hsNdiv(this)" href="javascript:()" title="4_1_1_1_1"><b>suppose </b></a><a NAME="E1:4_1_1_1_1"/>
( <font color="Maroon" title="c1">X</font> is <a href="xboole_0.html#V1" title="XBOOLE_0:attr.1">empty</a> &amp; <font color="Maroon" title="c2">Y</font> is <a href="xboole_0.html#V1" title="XBOOLE_0:attr.1">empty</a> )
 ; <a class="txt" onclick="hs(this)" href="javascript:()"><i><font color="Red">::  thesis: </font></i></a><span class="hide"> contradiction</span><br/><div class="add"><b>hence </b><a NAME="E2:4_1_1_1_1"/>
contradiction
 <b>by </b><i><a class="txt" href="#E3:4_1_1"><i><font color="Green" title="E3">A1</font></i></a></i>; <a class="txt" onclick="hs(this)" href="javascript:()"><i><font color="Red">::  thesis: </font></i></a><span class="hide"> verum</span><br/></div><b>end;</b></div><div><a class="txt" onclick="hsNdiv(this)" href="javascript:()" title="4_1_1_1_2"><b>suppose </b></a><a NAME="E1:4_1_1_1_2"/>
( <font color="Maroon" title="c1">X</font> is <a href="xboole_0.html#V1" title="XBOOLE_0:attr.1">empty</a> &amp;  ex <font color="Olive" title="b1">x</font> being   <a href="hidden.html#M1" title="HIDDEN:mode.1">set</a>  st <font color="Maroon" title="c2">Y</font> <a href="hidden.html#R1" title="HIDDEN:pred.1">=</a> <span class="p1"><a href="tarski.html#K1" title="TARSKI:func.1">{</a><span class="default"><font color="Olive" title="b1">x</font></span><a href="tarski.html#K1" title="TARSKI:func.1">}</a></span> )
 ; <a class="txt" onclick="hs(this)" href="javascript:()"><i><font color="Red">::  thesis: </font></i></a><span class="hide"> contradiction</span><br/><div class="add"><b>hence </b><a NAME="E2:4_1_1_1_2"/>
contradiction
 <b>by </b><i><a class="txt" href="#E3:4_1_1"><i><font color="Green" title="E3">A1</font></i></a></i>; <a class="txt" onclick="hs(this)" href="javascript:()"><i><font color="Red">::  thesis: </font></i></a><span class="hide"> verum</span><br/></div><b>end;</b></div><div><a class="txt" onclick="hsNdiv(this)" href="javascript:()" title="4_1_1_1_3"><b>suppose </b></a><a NAME="E1:4_1_1_1_3"/>
 ex <font color="Olive" title="b1">x</font> being   <a href="hidden.html#M1" title="HIDDEN:mode.1">set</a>  st <br/>( <font color="Maroon" title="c1">X</font> <a href="hidden.html#R1" title="HIDDEN:pred.1">=</a> <span class="p1"><a href="tarski.html#K1" title="TARSKI:func.1">{</a><span class="default"><font color="Olive" title="b1">x</font></span><a href="tarski.html#K1" title="TARSKI:func.1">}</a></span> &amp; <font color="Maroon" title="c2">Y</font> is <a href="xboole_0.html#V1" title="XBOOLE_0:attr.1">empty</a> )
 ; <a class="txt" onclick="hs(this)" href="javascript:()"><i><font color="Red">::  thesis: </font></i></a><span class="hide"> contradiction</span><br/><div class="add"><b>hence </b><a NAME="E2:4_1_1_1_3"/>
contradiction
 <b>by </b><i><a class="txt" href="#E3:4_1_1"><i><font color="Green" title="E3">A1</font></i></a></i>; <a class="txt" onclick="hs(this)" href="javascript:()"><i><font color="Red">::  thesis: </font></i></a><span class="hide"> verum</span><br/></div><b>end;</b></div><div><a class="txt" onclick="hsNdiv(this)" href="javascript:()" title="4_1_1_1_4"><b>suppose </b></a><a NAME="E1:4_1_1_1_4"/><i><font color="Green" title="E5">A3</font></i>: 
 ex <font color="Olive" title="b1">x</font> being   <a href="hidden.html#M1" title="HIDDEN:mode.1">set</a>  st <br/>( <font color="Maroon" title="c1">X</font> <a href="hidden.html#R1" title="HIDDEN:pred.1">=</a> <span class="p1"><a href="tarski.html#K1" title="TARSKI:func.1">{</a><span class="default"><font color="Olive" title="b1">x</font></span><a href="tarski.html#K1" title="TARSKI:func.1">}</a></span> &amp;  ex <font color="Olive" title="b2">y</font> being   <a href="hidden.html#M1" title="HIDDEN:mode.1">set</a>  st <font color="Maroon" title="c2">Y</font> <a href="hidden.html#R1" title="HIDDEN:pred.1">=</a> <span class="p1"><a href="tarski.html#K1" title="TARSKI:func.1">{</a><span class="default"><font color="Olive" title="b2">y</font></span><a href="tarski.html#K1" title="TARSKI:func.1">}</a></span> )
 ; <a class="txt" onclick="hs(this)" href="javascript:()"><i><font color="Red">::  thesis: </font></i></a><span class="hide"> contradiction</span><br/><div class="add"><b>then consider </b><font color="Maroon" title="c6">x</font> being    <a href="hidden.html#M1" title="HIDDEN:mode.1">set</a> <b> such that </b><br/><a NAME="E3:4_1_1_1_4"/><i><font color="Green" title="E6">A4</font></i>: 
<font color="Maroon" title="c1">X</font> <a href="hidden.html#R1" title="HIDDEN:pred.1">=</a> <span class="p1"><a href="tarski.html#K1" title="TARSKI:func.1">{</a><span class="default"><font color="Maroon" title="c6">x</font></span><a href="tarski.html#K1" title="TARSKI:func.1">}</a></span>
 ;<br/><b>consider </b><font color="Maroon" title="c7">y</font> being    <a href="hidden.html#M1" title="HIDDEN:mode.1">set</a> <b> such that </b><br/><a NAME="E5:4_1_1_1_4"/><i><font color="Green" title="E7">A5</font></i>: 
<font color="Maroon" title="c2">Y</font> <a href="hidden.html#R1" title="HIDDEN:pred.1">=</a> <span class="p1"><a href="tarski.html#K1" title="TARSKI:func.1">{</a><span class="default"><font color="Maroon" title="c7">y</font></span><a href="tarski.html#K1" title="TARSKI:func.1">}</a></span>
 <b>by </b><i><a class="txt" href="#E1:4_1_1_1_4"><i><font color="Green" title="E5">A3</font></i></a></i>;<br/><b>consider </b><font color="Maroon" title="c8">x1</font>, <font color="Maroon" title="c9">x2</font> being    <a href="hidden.html#M1" title="HIDDEN:mode.1">set</a> <b> such that </b><br/><a NAME="E7:4_1_1_1_4"/><i><font color="Green" title="E8">A6</font></i>: 
( <font color="Maroon" title="c4">a1</font> <a href="hidden.html#R1" title="HIDDEN:pred.1">=</a> <span class="p1"><a href="tarski.html#K4" title="TARSKI:func.4">[</a><span class="default"><font color="Maroon" title="c8">x1</font>,<font color="Maroon" title="c9">x2</font></span><a href="tarski.html#K4" title="TARSKI:func.4">]</a></span> &amp; <font color="Maroon" title="c8">x1</font> <a href="hidden.html#R2" title="HIDDEN:pred.2">in</a> <font color="Maroon" title="c1">X</font> &amp; <font color="Maroon" title="c9">x2</font> <a href="hidden.html#R2" title="HIDDEN:pred.2">in</a> <font color="Maroon" title="c2">Y</font> )
 <b>by </b><i><a class="txt" href="#E3:4_1_1"><i><font color="Green" title="E3">A1</font></i></a>, <a class="ref" href="relset_1.html#T6" title="RELSET_1:th.6">RELSET_1:6</a></i>;<br/><a NAME="E8:4_1_1_1_4"/><i><font color="Green" title="E9">A7</font></i>: 
( <font color="Maroon" title="c8">x1</font> <a href="hidden.html#R1" title="HIDDEN:pred.1">=</a> <font color="Maroon" title="c6">x</font> &amp; <font color="Maroon" title="c9">x2</font> <a href="hidden.html#R1" title="HIDDEN:pred.1">=</a> <font color="Maroon" title="c7">y</font> )
 <b>by </b><i><a class="txt" href="#E3:4_1_1_1_4"><i><font color="Green" title="E6">A4</font></i></a>, <a class="txt" href="#E5:4_1_1_1_4"><i><font color="Green" title="E7">A5</font></i></a>, <a class="txt" href="#E7:4_1_1_1_4"><i><font color="Green" title="E8">A6</font></i></a>, <a class="ref" href="tarski.html#D1" title="TARSKI:def.1">TARSKI:def 1</a></i>;<br/><b>consider </b><font color="Maroon" title="c10">y1</font>, <font color="Maroon" title="c11">y2</font> being    <a href="hidden.html#M1" title="HIDDEN:mode.1">set</a> <b> such that </b><br/><a NAME="E10:4_1_1_1_4"/><i><font color="Green" title="E10">A8</font></i>: 
( <font color="Maroon" title="c5">a2</font> <a href="hidden.html#R1" title="HIDDEN:pred.1">=</a> <span class="p1"><a href="tarski.html#K4" title="TARSKI:func.4">[</a><span class="default"><font color="Maroon" title="c10">y1</font>,<font color="Maroon" title="c11">y2</font></span><a href="tarski.html#K4" title="TARSKI:func.4">]</a></span> &amp; <font color="Maroon" title="c10">y1</font> <a href="hidden.html#R2" title="HIDDEN:pred.2">in</a> <font color="Maroon" title="c1">X</font> &amp; <font color="Maroon" title="c11">y2</font> <a href="hidden.html#R2" title="HIDDEN:pred.2">in</a> <font color="Maroon" title="c2">Y</font> )
 <b>by </b><i><a class="txt" href="#E3:4_1_1"><i><font color="Green" title="E3">A1</font></i></a>, <a class="ref" href="relset_1.html#T6" title="RELSET_1:th.6">RELSET_1:6</a></i>;<br/><a NAME="E11:4_1_1_1_4"/>
( <font color="Maroon" title="c10">y1</font> <a href="hidden.html#R1" title="HIDDEN:pred.1">=</a> <font color="Maroon" title="c6">x</font> &amp; <font color="Maroon" title="c11">y2</font> <a href="hidden.html#R1" title="HIDDEN:pred.1">=</a> <font color="Maroon" title="c7">y</font> )
 <b>by </b><i><a class="txt" href="#E3:4_1_1_1_4"><i><font color="Green" title="E6">A4</font></i></a>, <a class="txt" href="#E5:4_1_1_1_4"><i><font color="Green" title="E7">A5</font></i></a>, <a class="txt" href="#E10:4_1_1_1_4"><i><font color="Green" title="E10">A8</font></i></a>, <a class="ref" href="tarski.html#D1" title="TARSKI:def.1">TARSKI:def 1</a></i>;<br/><b>hence </b><a NAME="E12:4_1_1_1_4"/>
contradiction
 <b>by </b><i><a class="txt" href="#E3:4_1_1"><i><font color="Green" title="E3">A1</font></i></a>, <a class="txt" href="#E7:4_1_1_1_4"><i><font color="Green" title="E8">A6</font></i></a>, <a class="txt" href="#E8:4_1_1_1_4"><i><font color="Green" title="E9">A7</font></i></a>, <a class="txt" href="#E10:4_1_1_1_4"><i><font color="Green" title="E10">A8</font></i></a></i>; <a class="txt" onclick="hs(this)" href="javascript:()"><i><font color="Red">::  thesis: </font></i></a><span class="hide"> verum</span><br/></div><b>end;</b></div></div><b>end;</b></div>

</div>
